Comment Only Marking

The strategy, as published

Exactly as it appears on the card

Comment Only Marking

Remove grades from work in progress. Research showed comments alone produced the greatest gains. Adding a score to a comment cancels it out: students read the grade and ignore the feedback entirely.

Suggested technology digital annotation or LMS tool · Informed by Butler, Wiliam

Find this under Make feedback more useful

Part of Feedback That Moves Learning Forward in 02 Formative Assessment, where it sits alongside its neighbouring strategies, the infographic and the thinking for the whole area. New to the idea? Read What is formative assessment? A teacher's guide.

Why you might use it

The problem it may help with

Butler's finding is stark enough that the card leads with it: comments alone produced the greatest gains, and adding a grade to the comment cancelled it out. Given both, pupils read the grade, compare it with their neighbour's, and the comment might as well not be there at all.

So for work in progress, taking the grades away protects the only part of the marking that can still change the work. That's all this strategy is, and it costs nothing to try.

What it could look like

One way in your classroom

You return a practice paper with comments identifying the strongest section and the step where marks were lost, and no score anywhere. The first ten minutes of the lesson go on acting on those comments, and scores only appear when the unit's final assessment arrives.

Try it

A way to begin

Choose one piece of work in progress from one class and mark it comment only. Then watch what pupils do with the comments when there's no grade to look at first.

What to notice

Reading what happens

  • Where pupils' eyes go when work comes back, and how many actually read past a grade when one is there.
  • Whether your comments give pupils something they can actually go and do, because that's what makes the comment worth more than the grade.

Things to think about

Before and while you use it

  • Work in progress is the card's boundary. Summative pieces still get graded, and the change protects feedback while the work can still improve.
  • Some marking policies expect grades on every piece, and how comment only marking sits with that expectation is your judgement, and sometimes a conversation in the department, rather than something a website can settle.

The wider thinking

Where the evidence sits

Butler compared grades, comments and the two combined. The gains sat with comments alone, and the combination did no better than grades by themselves. The card’s attribution stands as published: Butler, Wiliam.

The fuller picture, sources included, is in further reading and evidence for Formative Assessment.

Keep exploring

Where next?

Back to this strategy in 02 Formative Assessment, across to what you're trying to improve, or into all 144 at once.

Want to take this further?

Support is available

Pedagogy First gives you a starting point. If you want support exploring how approaches like this can work across your school, trust or professional learning programme, that work is available.

Work with Mark