One Third Makes It Worse

The strategy, as published

Exactly as it appears on the card

One Third Makes It Worse

Over a third of feedback interventions decrease performance. Before giving feedback, check: does this comment address the work or the student? If it is about the student, rewrite it.

Suggested technology feedback audit or review tool · Informed by Kluger & DeNisi

Part of What Feedback Is in 03 Feedback, where it sits alongside its neighbouring strategies, the infographic and the thinking for the whole area. New to the idea? Read What is effective feedback? A teacher's guide.

Why you might use it

The problem it may help with

Kluger and DeNisi's finding is one of the most sobering in this strand, because over a third of the feedback interventions they looked at actually made performance worse. Feedback is powerful, and it turns out it can be powerful in the wrong direction too.

The dividing line in their analysis is where the attention goes. Comments that keep a pupil's attention on the work tend to help, and comments that pull attention onto the self tend not to. The check on the card, work or student, is simply the practical version of that finding.

What it could look like

One way in your classroom

Before returning books, you read your own comments as if you were the pupil receiving them. Two turn out to be about the pupil rather than the translation in front of them, so both get rewritten to name something in the work, such as "this tense is the one to fix", or "these five words need the accent check you used above".

What to notice

Reading what happens

  • How pupils respond in the moment work is returned, whether that's heads down into the work or looking around comparing themselves with others.
  • Which of your comments you'd be glad to receive about your own work, because reading them that way round is a quick and honest check.

Things to think about

Before and while you use it

  • A comment can be about the student without ever naming them. Try harder, more effort needed and you can do better are all self-directed, whatever the phrasing.

The wider thinking

Where the evidence sits

As the strand's opening argument puts it, some feedback helps, some does very little, and some makes things worse, and Kluger and DeNisi supplied the numbers behind that sentence. The card’s attribution stands as published: Kluger & DeNisi.

The fuller picture, sources included, is in further reading and evidence for Feedback.

Keep exploring

Where next?

Back to this strategy in 03 Feedback, across to what you're trying to improve, or into all 144 at once.

Want to take this further?

Support is available

Pedagogy First gives you a starting point. If you want support exploring how approaches like this can work across your school, trust or professional learning programme, that work is available.

Work with Mark