Comment Only, No Grades
Butler found comments alone produced the greatest gains. A grade cancels the comment: students see the score and skip the words. If grades are mandated, delay until feedback is used.
Find this under Make feedback more useful
The strategy, as published
Butler found comments alone produced the greatest gains. A grade cancels the comment: students see the score and skip the words. If grades are mandated, delay until feedback is used.
Find this under Make feedback more useful
Part of Timing & Frequency in 03 Feedback, where it sits alongside its neighbouring strategies, the infographic and the thinking for the whole area. New to the idea? Read What is effective feedback? A teacher's guide.
Why you might use it
Butler's study gives this strand one of its clearest warnings. When a grade sits alongside a comment, pupils look at the grade and miss the guidance, and it was comments alone that produced the greatest gains.
It's worth being clear about how strong the effect is, because the grade doesn't just distract a bit from the comment. In Butler's study, adding the grade wiped the comment's benefit out altogether, and two lines of careful writing in the margin simply can't compete with a number at the top of the page.
What it could look like
You return assessed work with comments only. Pupils respond to the comments and improve one section, and only then, at the end of the week, do the grades go into the gradebook and become visible.
Try it
Choose one low-stakes piece and return it comment-only, then compare what pupils do with it against what they did last time a grade was attached.
What to notice
Things to think about
Technology second
Most digital gradebooks and annotation tools show pupils a score the moment work is returned, which puts Butler's problem straight back on the screen. If the approved tool in your setting has a hide-grades or scheduled-release option, it's well worth using, so pupils get the comments first, then time to respond, and the number afterwards.
The wider thinking
Butler's research distinguished task-involving from ego-involving feedback, and a grade pulls attention towards how I did as a person, which is precisely the attention shift Kluger and DeNisi found so costly. The card’s attribution stands as published: Butler.
The fuller picture, sources included, is in further reading and evidence for Feedback.
Keep exploring
Back to this strategy in 03 Feedback, across to what you're trying to improve, or into all 144 at once.
Want to take this further?
Pedagogy First gives you a starting point. If you want support exploring how approaches like this can work across your school, trust or professional learning programme, that work is available.