Why you might use it
The problem it may help with
Willingham's line, that memory is the residue of thought, is the whole argument here. A pupil who offloads the thinking to AI hasn't done any thinking, so there's no residue, and nothing gets learned, however polished the work looks.
The distinction the card draws is between AI producing the reasoning and AI challenging reasoning the pupil has already done. The first is substitution, and it takes away the very capacity this strand is trying to build. The second can work like an external check, provided the judging of the critique stays with the pupil.