Why you might use it
The problem it may help with
A rubric can describe quality, but it can't really show it. A pupil can read 'uses precise vocabulary' and nod along without any real idea of what precision looks like in this subject at this level. Put two pieces of work side by side though, and the difference becomes something they can actually point at.
There's a second advantage the card names too, which is that pupils spot quality in someone else's work far more readily than in their own, so judging an exemplar is really useful practice for the harder job of judging themselves.